Are Subway Systems SAFE Anymore?
Two unprovoked assaults on New York City MTA employees in Brooklyn have intensified calls for stronger protections, highlighting the risks transit workers face during daily operations.
At a Glance
• Two MTA workers assaulted in Brooklyn in June and July
• Suspects in July 1 incident arrested and charged with assault and menacing
• Attacks linked to fare evasion confrontations at subway turnstiles
• Transport Workers Union calls for tougher penalties and stronger security
• MTA commits to enhanced worker protection measures
Recent Incidents Raise Alarm
New York City’s Metropolitan Transportation Authority is confronting renewed scrutiny after two separate assaults on transit employees occurred in Brooklyn within weeks of each other. On June 15, a 68-year-old MTA worker was attacked in Boerum Hill while performing routine duties. Less than three weeks later, on July 1, 51-year-old Marshalee Reid was assaulted by two women at the New Lots Avenue No. 3 train station.
Arrests were made in the July 1 case on July 15 and July 23, with suspects Ayizhae Thomas and Leschea Aldridge facing multiple charges, including assault and menacing. Authorities have indicated that both incidents were unprovoked and occurred in the context of fare evasion, a persistent issue in the subway system.
Watch now: MTA Workers Face Rising Assaults · YouTube
These events have prompted a wave of concern among transit workers and the public, reigniting debates over whether existing measures are sufficient to deter violence in the city’s subway network.
Union Push for Action
The Transport Workers Union has responded by urging lawmakers and city officials to increase penalties for those who attack transit employees. Union leaders argue that a combination of stronger deterrents, heightened enforcement, and visible security presence is necessary to protect staff and reassure riders.
MTA officials have echoed these concerns, with senior figures calling for “maximum justice” in prosecuting perpetrators. Proposals include increasing police patrols at high-risk stations, enhancing surveillance coverage, and improving support services for injured employees. Such measures are seen as essential not only for worker safety but also for maintaining operational stability in one of the world’s busiest transit systems.
Balancing Enforcement and Prevention
Experts in transit security note that while stricter enforcement is an important step, it may not be enough to address the underlying tensions that lead to violent confrontations. Fare evasion remains a flashpoint, and direct confrontations at turnstiles can escalate quickly. Specialists advocate for a dual strategy—combining visible enforcement with de-escalation training for MTA staff to reduce risk.
Some suggest exploring non-confrontational fare collection methods, such as remote monitoring or redesigned station entry systems, to limit situations in which employees are placed in harm’s way. This approach could reduce physical confrontations while preserving revenue integrity.
Broader Policy Implications
The recent assaults could influence safety protocols beyond New York City. Other major metropolitan transit systems are closely monitoring developments, evaluating whether similar risks exist within their operations. Cities across the United States may consider adopting more robust security and worker protection measures, using New York’s experience as a case study.
Long-term safety improvements will likely require ongoing coordination between transit authorities, law enforcement, unions, and policymakers. While the immediate focus remains on addressing recent incidents, the larger challenge lies in building a system that safeguards workers without creating an adversarial relationship between staff and the riding public.
Sources