Brendan Carr Demands Transparency From Big Tech Over Censorship Allegations

FCC Commissioner Brendan Carr has ramped up his criticism of Big Tech, accusing companies of operating a “censorship cartel” that undermines free speech. His remarks come as social media platforms like X thrive, while traditional networks like MSNBC experience a post-election ratings slump.

Carr’s accusations were detailed in an open letter to the CEOs of Apple, Meta, Google, and Microsoft. He alleged that these companies work with organizations like NewsGuard to enforce biased narratives and stifle dissent. “The censorship cartel must be dismantled,” Carr stated.

The commissioner highlighted NewsGuard’s role in influencing advertising decisions, accusing it of penalizing outlets that challenge prevailing viewpoints. Carr cited findings from the Twitter Files and a U.S. House Committee on Small Business report, which criticized NewsGuard for unfairly favoring certain media while suppressing others.

Carr also raised concerns about NewsGuard’s credibility, pointing to its favorable ratings for Chinese propaganda compared to American sources. He argued these actions violate the “good faith” requirements of Section 230 and called for greater oversight of such practices.

To hold Big Tech accountable, Carr requested that companies disclose all products and services involving NewsGuard or similar organizations by December 10. He emphasized that Americans have a right to free expression without interference from biased third parties.

Carr’s letter reflects a broader push for transparency in the tech industry. He urged companies to dismantle censorship practices, warning that continued suppression of free speech poses a threat to democracy.